Showing posts with label great idea. Show all posts
Showing posts with label great idea. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 9, 2009

Girl in the Arena, Lise Haines, Bloomsbury, 324 pages


(Nov. 19)I so very much wanted to love this book.

Really I did.

And it’s not that I didn’t like it.

It’s that I didn’t love it.

It was kind of lackluster for me.

There was sooooo much explaining. I mean the main character, Lyn, did so much explaining, about who people were, what the Gladiator Association was and who started it and how it evolved.

For me none of the characters stood out. I didn’t feel a deep connection with any of them. It seemed too fast paced in relation to the characters. Like I caught snippets of them but they were always out of my reach. Two dimensional.

I loved the fact that Ms. Haines introduced a special needs character (being that I worked with kids like this for four wonderful, rewarding, hard years ) and had him as such an integral part of the story and also a pretty cool one. I loved his Oracle-ness. Thought it was a nice touch.

The other character that I liked most was Uber. The Neo-gladiator hero that Lyn is supposed to marry.

I loved his clumsy-ness around her, I loved his openness, I loved his thick glasses. I don’t know, it’s like he was a dork but everyone adored him and wanted him.

Overall it was a good story, just not enough dialogue for me, not enough character building. Not sure if there’s going to be another in this series, but if so, we have the foundation laid out for us nicely.


If I did this I’d give it 3 out of 5 stars.


Crazy Beautiful, Lauren Baratz-Logsted, Houghton Mifflin, 193 pages


(Nov. 15)What to say.

I liked it.

But it wasn’t spectacular for me.

I swear it’s got to be the shorter books that I never feel satisfied with.

I think my overall feeling is one of being let down. It was a really great premise. Really. I mean a boy with hooks for arms and a girl that falls in love with him. Great potential and I think Lauren did a good job with the first 166 pages.

It’s from 167 till the end that just seemed rushed. And frankly, for me, unbelievable.

Seriously I’m just sick to death of characters that don’t try to talk to each other when things start unraveling. Just try!

So, that’s it.

I really did like it and I’m sure there are other blogs out there that give glowing reviews.

I just couldn’t.

If I rated books, which I may start doing I’d give it a three out of five. So not bad, but not great.